VPN

Surfshark vs ExpressVPN: Which Should You Use?

A practical comparison of features, pricing, ease of use, best use cases and value for money.

See Winner Compare Features

Quick verdict

Best overall

Surfshark

Best for beginners

ExpressVPN

Best value

Surfshark

Best for professionals

ExpressVPN

Best free option

Surfshark

Final recommendation

Pick Surfshark for households and value; pick ExpressVPN if app polish and streaming come first.

Side-by-side

Surfshark vs ExpressVPN at a glance

Criteria	Surfshark	ExpressVPN
Main use case	Value VPN for many devices	Premium streaming + travel VPN
Simultaneous devices	Unlimited	8
Protocol	WireGuard	Lightway
Streaming reliability	Very good	Excellent
Extras	CleanWeb, Alternative ID, Antivirus (add-on)	TrustedServer, threat manager
Pricing	From ~$2.19/mo (24-month + 3 free)	From ~$6.67/mo (1-year)
Best for	Families, many devices	Streaming + travel
Weaknesses	Some extras cost more	Higher price
ToolMoneyLab score	90 / 100	87 / 100
CTA	Try Surfshark →	Try ExpressVPN →

Choose Surfshark if…

Choose Surfshark if you want to cover an entire household on one subscription at the best price.

Choose ExpressVPN if…

Choose ExpressVPN if you'll happily pay more for the smoothest apps and the most reliable streaming.

Feature-by-feature breakdown

The details that matter

Feature	Surfshark	ExpressVPN
Main use case	Value VPN for many devices	Premium streaming + travel VPN
Simultaneous devices	Unlimited	8
Protocol	WireGuard	Lightway
Streaming reliability	Very good	Excellent
Extras	CleanWeb, Alternative ID, Antivirus (add-on)	TrustedServer, threat manager
Pricing	From ~$2.19/mo (24-month + 3 free)	From ~$6.67/mo (1-year)
Best for	Families, many devices	Streaming + travel
Weaknesses	Some extras cost more	Higher price
ToolMoneyLab score	90 / 100	87 / 100

Pricing comparison

What you'll actually pay

Surfshark's 24-month plan often drops below $2.50/mo; ExpressVPN sits around $6.67/mo on its best plan. Both refund within 30 days.

Pricing changes frequently, so always check the official website before subscribing.

Pros and cons

What we liked and didn't

Surfshark — Pros

Unlimited simultaneous devices
CleanWeb ad and tracker blocking
Alternative ID and Antivirus add-ons
Aggressive multi-year pricing

Surfshark — Cons

Not quite ExpressVPN's polish
Some features (Antivirus) cost extra

ExpressVPN — Pros

Reliable streaming across major platforms
Lightway protocol optimised for mobile
TrustedServer RAM-only architecture
Best-in-class app polish

ExpressVPN — Cons

More expensive than Surfshark
8 simultaneous device limit

Final verdict

The bottom line

Choose Surfshark if…

Choose Surfshark for households and value.

Choose ExpressVPN if…

Choose ExpressVPN when the experience matters more than the price.

The Tool Money Lab Verdict

Our editorial call on Surfshark vs ExpressVPN

After spending real time with both Surfshark and ExpressVPN, our editorial view is that these tools solve overlapping problems in very different ways. Surfshark is built for households and users with many devices on a tight budget., while ExpressVPN is aimed at travelers and streamers who want it to just work.. Neither is objectively "better" — the right answer depends on the work you actually do, not on which product has the flashier launch video.

Surfshark takes the edge on our internal scorecard (90/100 vs 87/100), but that headline number hides the nuance. Surfshark tends to win on unlimited simultaneous devices, while ExpressVPN pulls ahead on reliable streaming across major platforms. If your workflow leans heavily into either of those, the "winner" for you changes.

Our recommendation is to pick the tool that matches the way you already work, rather than the one with the broader marketing footprint. The gap between them is not large enough to justify fighting your own habits — but it is large enough that the wrong choice will cost you time every day for months.

We recommend Surfshark to…

Households
users with many devices on a tight budget

We recommend ExpressVPN to…

Travelers
streamers who want it to just work

Where Surfshark clearly wins

Unlimited simultaneous devices
CleanWeb ad and tracker blocking
Alternative ID and Antivirus add-ons

Where ExpressVPN clearly wins

Reliable streaming across major platforms
Lightway protocol optimised for mobile
TrustedServer RAM-only architecture

Trade-offs to know

Surfshark: Not quite ExpressVPN's polish
ExpressVPN: More expensive than Surfshark

Value for money

On pure value, Surfshark currently offers the stronger price-to-capability ratio for its target audience, but ExpressVPN remains the better spend when its speciality is the deciding factor.

Overall recommendation

Most readers should start with Surfshark for households and users with many devices on a tight budget., and consider ExpressVPN when travelers and streamers who want it to just work. is the dominant use case.

Why we made this recommendation

How The Tool Money Lab evaluates every comparison

Every comparison published by The Tool Money Lab is written by editors who use these products in day-to-day work. We weigh the factors below against the reader profile the comparison is aimed at, and we call out situations where the affiliate-linked product is NOT the right choice. Where we have used a product extensively ourselves — Lovable is the clearest example, since this site is built with it — we disclose that in the review. Where a recommendation includes affiliate links, we may earn a commission when you sign up, at no additional cost to you. Affiliate relationships never change the editorial conclusion: if the paid product is worse for you, we say so.

Features

Ease of use

Performance

Reliability

Security

Privacy

Value for money

Business suitability

Ecosystem

Customer support

Long-term usability

Commercial model

Real-world testing where applicable

Independent research

Disclosure: pages on The Tool Money Lab may contain affiliate links. We may earn a commission when you sign up through them, at no additional cost to you. Affiliate relationships never change our editorial conclusion — if a paid product is the wrong choice for you, we say so.

Try them yourself

VPN

Surfshark

Value-first VPN with unlimited simultaneous connections.

Best for: Households and users with many devices on a tight budget.

Try Surfshark →Read review

VPN

ExpressVPN

Premium VPN with the smoothest apps and reliable streaming access.

Best for: Travelers and streamers who want it to just work.

Try ExpressVPN →Read review

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you sign up through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. Our comparisons remain independent and based on practical testing.

Frequently asked