Privacy & Security

SimpleLogin vs Proton Pass: Which Should You Use?

A practical comparison of features, pricing, ease of use, best use cases and value for money.

See Winner Compare Features

Quick verdict

Best overall

Proton Pass

Best for beginners

Proton Pass

Best value

Proton Pass

Best for professionals

Proton Pass

Best free option

Proton Pass

Final recommendation

Alias-only users pick SimpleLogin; users wanting a password manager too pick Proton Pass.

Side-by-side

SimpleLogin vs Proton Pass at a glance

Criteria	SimpleLogin	Proton Pass
Main use case	Users who want per-service email aliases.	Proton users wanting a password manager + aliases.
Key strength	Unlimited aliases (paid)	Built-in email aliases
Best for	Users who want per-service email aliases.	Proton users wanting a password manager + aliases.
Pricing	See official site	See official site
ToolMoneyLab score	85 / 100	87 / 100
CTA	Try SimpleLogin →	Try Proton Pass →

Choose SimpleLogin if…

Choose SimpleLogin if you want users who want per-service email aliases.

Choose Proton Pass if…

Choose Proton Pass if you want proton users wanting a password manager + aliases.

Feature-by-feature breakdown

The details that matter

Feature	SimpleLogin	Proton Pass
Ease of use	Unlimited aliases (paid)	Built-in email aliases
Output / feature quality	Proton-owned	Included in Proton bundles
Integrations / ecosystem	PGP support	Simple, private
Best professional use	Users who want per-service email aliases.	Proton users wanting a password manager + aliases.

Pricing comparison

What you'll actually pay

Pricing changes frequently, so always check the official website before subscribing.

Pros and cons

What we liked and didn't

SimpleLogin — Pros

Unlimited aliases (paid)
Proton-owned
PGP support

SimpleLogin — Cons

Requires forwarding mindset
Free tier has alias limits

Proton Pass — Pros

Built-in email aliases
Included in Proton bundles
Simple, private

Proton Pass — Cons

Newer than 1Password/Bitwarden
Fewer power-user features

Final verdict

The bottom line

Choose SimpleLogin if…

Choose SimpleLogin for users who want per-service email aliases.

Choose Proton Pass if…

Choose Proton Pass for proton users wanting a password manager + aliases.

Explore the Proton ecosystem →

The Tool Money Lab Verdict

Our editorial call on SimpleLogin vs Proton Pass

After spending real time with both SimpleLogin and Proton Pass, our editorial view is that these tools solve overlapping problems in very different ways. SimpleLogin is built for users who want per-service email aliases., while Proton Pass is aimed at proton users wanting a password manager + aliases.. Neither is objectively "better" — the right answer depends on the work you actually do, not on which product has the flashier launch video.

Proton Pass takes the edge on our internal scorecard (87/100 vs 85/100), but that headline number hides the nuance. SimpleLogin tends to win on unlimited aliases (paid), while Proton Pass pulls ahead on built-in email aliases. If your workflow leans heavily into either of those, the "winner" for you changes.

Our recommendation is to pick the tool that matches the way you already work, rather than the one with the broader marketing footprint. The gap between them is not large enough to justify fighting your own habits — but it is large enough that the wrong choice will cost you time every day for months.

We recommend SimpleLogin to…

Users who want per-service email aliases

We recommend Proton Pass to…

Proton users wanting a password manager + aliases

Where SimpleLogin clearly wins

Unlimited aliases (paid)
Proton-owned
PGP support

Where Proton Pass clearly wins

Built-in email aliases
Included in Proton bundles
Simple, private

Trade-offs to know

SimpleLogin: Requires forwarding mindset
Proton Pass: Newer than 1Password/Bitwarden

Value for money

On pure value, Proton Pass currently offers the stronger price-to-capability ratio for its target audience, but SimpleLogin remains the better spend when its speciality is the deciding factor.

Overall recommendation

Most readers should start with Proton Pass for proton users wanting a password manager + aliases., and consider SimpleLogin when users who want per-service email aliases. is the dominant use case.

Why we made this recommendation

How The Tool Money Lab evaluates every comparison

Every comparison published by The Tool Money Lab is written by editors who use these products in day-to-day work. We weigh the factors below against the reader profile the comparison is aimed at, and we call out situations where the affiliate-linked product is NOT the right choice. Where we have used a product extensively ourselves — Lovable is the clearest example, since this site is built with it — we disclose that in the review. Where a recommendation includes affiliate links, we may earn a commission when you sign up, at no additional cost to you. Affiliate relationships never change the editorial conclusion: if the paid product is worse for you, we say so.

Features

Ease of use

Performance

Reliability

Security

Privacy

Value for money

Business suitability

Ecosystem

Customer support

Long-term usability

Commercial model

Real-world testing where applicable

Independent research

Disclosure: pages on The Tool Money Lab may contain affiliate links. We may earn a commission when you sign up through them, at no additional cost to you. Affiliate relationships never change our editorial conclusion — if a paid product is the wrong choice for you, we say so.

Try them yourself

Privacy & Security

SimpleLogin

Email alias service to hide your real address.

Best for: Users who want per-service email aliases.

Try SimpleLogin →Read review

Password Manager

Proton Pass

Proton's password manager with built-in email aliases.

Best for: Proton users wanting a password manager + aliases.

Try Proton Pass →Read review

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you sign up through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. Our comparisons remain editorially independent. This one is based on the vendors' published product, pricing and compliance documentation rather than hands-on testing, and each review states its evidence class.

Frequently asked